The Keys at

PUT-IN-BAY

The Keys is Closed for the Season!
See you in the Spring of 2027!

At The Keys
we bring Florida flair!

Enjoy waterfront views from every seat, the island's only fire pit, live Tiki deck entertainment, and a Caribbean-style menu with gourmet sandwiches, fresh salads, flatbreads, burgers, and delightful cocktails. Put-in-Bay’s home to the largest variety of Frozen Cocktails. You may never want to leave!

Find your view and make island memories with us.

Specials / Events

Don't miss out on the fun!

Take their word for it!

“Super menu. Food is delicious. For vegetarian, black bean burger with a side of rice and beans, sweet potato fries is great. Their chicken soup is good too. Great service.”

“This place is a diamond in the rough. Dinner was delicious. Customer service was wonderful. After dinner they had music, her name was Toby Lee, and she was wonderful. Very entertaining. It was a bit more relaxing than downtown.”

“Loved it. Live music, great atmosphere and friendly staff. Seating outside or inside. This place is located near the Jet Express ferry ⛴️.”

“Sat right on the water. The frozen drinks were great (especially the 151) I had a Reuben Sandwich made with walleye. The waiter was great. We went at sunset, and it was amazing.”

Take their word for it!

“Super menu. Food is delicious. For vegetarian, black bean burger with a side of rice and beans, sweet potato fries is great. Their chicken soup is good too. Great service.”

“This place is a diamond in the rough. Dinner was delicious. Customer service was wonderful. After dinner they had music, her name was Toby Lee, and she was wonderful.”

“Loved it. Live music, great atmosphere and friendly staff. Seating outside or inside. This place is located near the Jet Express ferry ⛴️.”

“Sat right on the water. The frozen drinks were great (especially the 151) I had a Reuben Sandwich made with walleye. The waiter was great. We went at sunset, and it was amazing.”